dira: Bucky Barnes/The Winter Soldier (Hathaway and Lewis)
Dira Sudis ([personal profile] dira) wrote2012-02-10 02:49 pm

Purely hypothetical, obvs

If James Hathaway were going to play/sing a song to entertain/distract/soothe a very young child (old enough to learn/sing/repeat/ask about any lyrics he includes), what would he play and/or sing?

For those not familiar with Hathaway and his demonstrated musical preferences:

1. He's an English guy--from Oxfordshire, educated at Cambridge, nearly became a Catholic priest but wound up a cop--born in the late 70s or so. He's about 30 at the time the hypothetical situation is taking place.

2. The hypothetical situation is taking place a few years ago. Any music from 2009 to the present is off limits, much as I would love to have him singing Lady Gaga.

3. He plays guitar in a group that does "world music with elements of jazz, rock, and medieval madrigals".

4. He went to a world music festival wearing a RUN DMC t-shirt. Uh. IDEK.

5. Given the opportunity he turns off Wagner and puts on "The Boys Are Back in Town" at Lewis's place.

6. He plays a 1948 Gibson L5 PE Guitar with a honey-blond finish and a Charlie Christian pickup, and has collected the autographs of several famous guitarists whose names I (shamefully, I am sure) don't recognize: Martin Taylor, Dave Cliff, Phil Lee, Pat Metheny, Russell Malone....
sage: Still of Natasha Romanova from Iron Man 2 (Default)

[personal profile] sage 2012-02-10 09:53 pm (UTC)(link)
Well, an easy if cliched answer is the Beatles because they're very child-friendly. I mean, "I am the walrus!" is FUN with six-year-olds because they don't need ulterior meanings. Also, Beatles songs are something beginning guitarists tend to learn (along with Led Zep & Hendrix, but those are somewhat less appropriate here *g*).

Also, I've known a LOT of families who use Beatles songs for singing babies to sleep. Better "Here Comes the Sun" than "Rockabye Baby", you know? So they're kind of my default suggestion? OTOH, he's so iconoclastic sometimes that I can also see a case for him sneering at the Beatles as being rather too much the done thing. On the 3rd hand, I can see him saying, "Well it was good enough for my mum to sing to me when I was your age!"

Okay, NOW I want to go and catch up on my viewing! (I'm in mid-series 3 right now.)

[personal profile] doctor_denmark 2012-02-10 11:29 pm (UTC)(link)
something by the Beatles. probably something like "I want to hold your hand" or "love me do" I remember them from my childhood, and I'm probably 7 or 8 years younger than Hathaway, and from the same part of the world.
riverlight: A rainbow and birds. (lewis: lewis & hathaway)

[personal profile] riverlight 2012-02-10 11:32 pm (UTC)(link)
I agree with [personal profile] sage; the Beatles are a safe bet...

I was going to say maybe Nick Drake, but then I saw the bit about said child repeating lyrics and thought, well, maybe not. (Nothing wrong with the lyrics to Pink Moon, per se, but if she's a curious child—and who isn't at that age?—she might well wonder what it means and he'd have no answer).

In a similar vein, how about Donovan? Ballad of Geraldine is a good one... Neither of those two would be ones James had grown up with, necessarily—a little before his time—but given his interest in music that falls (shall we say) out of the norm for his generation, I wouldn't be at all surprised if he knew them.
tricksterquinn: Moira MacTaggert in trenchcoat & umbrella gazing seriously out of frame. It's muted & pensive & lovely. (Default)

[personal profile] tricksterquinn 2012-02-11 12:22 am (UTC)(link)
I like the idea of Pink Moon, and I don't expect most adults would think to worry that the kid might ask about the meaning of that particular song?
riverlight: A rainbow and birds. (Default)

[personal profile] riverlight 2012-02-11 12:33 am (UTC)(link)
Well, selfishly, I just love the idea of Hathaway singing music that I myself think is wonderful, but I also do think seriously that he'd know Drake, so. Hey, if Dira likes it...

(Though: no pressure, d!)
riverlight: A rainbow and birds. (Default)

[personal profile] riverlight 2012-02-15 09:44 pm (UTC)(link)
Because everyone needs Swedish orchestral pop in their lives.

Clearly!

And I'm soooo glad you included Drake. I confess, as soon as I started thinking about it I got all excited, and then when I wrote it up in this comment I just got so caught up in the idea that it's now my head canon. So. Yay Hathaway playing Nick Drake on his guitar = love.

(ALSO MIDNIGHT ADDICTION YES.)
glittertine: (Lewis - boys - by luredin)

[personal profile] glittertine 2012-02-10 11:39 pm (UTC)(link)
You don't like the Run-DMC shirt? I LOVE THE RUN-DMC shirt. I have had many minutes of joy imagining Hathaway wearing it. And rewatching him wearing it. ♥.♥

Unfortunately, I have no idea what he'd sing. I went through everything I love from the time he (and I, same age) was impressionable, but none of it is suitable for singing to children. XD
riverlight: A rainbow and birds. (lewis: lewis & hathaway)

[personal profile] riverlight 2012-02-11 12:35 am (UTC)(link)
It thrilled me to bits to see him in a Run-DMC shirt!! (Though I agree, I did go "wait, what?" when I saw he was wearing it at the world music festival, but then again, I've always heard the rule of "don't wear the band's shirt to the band's own concerts," so maybe he was just taking it to a logical extreme and wearing a shirt from a whole different genre on purpose? Either way, I like what it says about the versatility of his musical taste!)
molly_o: (Default)

[personal profile] molly_o 2012-02-11 01:42 am (UTC)(link)
Depends on the purpose. Trying to get V to sleep, we settled on American Pie, because we could sing it once in lieu of singing "Hush Little Baby" 10-15 times. I don't know if it has the same connotations internationally though.

I don't know ... is there something by Fela Kuti? Or Sun Ra?

Or, in a totally different vein, old Chicago (Saturday in the Park)

Or maybe Santana. Or Robbie Williams. (I think random is good in this instance; it seems all the other musical references are deliberately designed to foil any attempts to categorize him musically.)

(Tiny Dancer?)

gingicat: deep purple lilacs, some buds, some open (Default)

[personal profile] gingicat 2012-02-11 11:39 pm (UTC)(link)
I am amused that I am not the only person who thought of the Beatles. The Yellow Submarine movie popped instantly into my head.