dira: Bucky Barnes/The Winter Soldier (Default)
Dira Sudis ([personal profile] dira) wrote2019-04-26 09:23 pm

A compliation of my Endgame reaction posts from Tumblr

Under the tag: all the spoilers, none of the squee. Click at own risk.

My Endgame reactions on Tumblr today, a play in three acts.



#1

My reaction, after twelve hours:

image

[STOP READING THERE IF YOU REALLY ENJOYED THE MOVIE AND ARE HAPPY ABOUT HOW IT ENDED, I WAS UP REALLY LATE LAST NIGHT AND I’M TIRED! HAHA!]

…Anyway, I wish I actually meant that humorously in the sense that I was awake until 2 in the morning between seeing the movie and hashing out my feelings about it, but, no, I just mean…

Look, I can see ways to bend and twist and reconstruct the material that movie gave us into a lot of fun and enjoyable and great fic? But at this point I don’t even want to because I am just. so. fucking. tired. of engaging with a canon that thought THOSE were good endings for the characters I’ve spent a decade bonding with. What the actual fuck. I keep trying to like, rank the original six’s endings in order of which I am most to least mad about, but I just–what the actual everliving fuck.

Also it is sort of impressive, in a trainwrecky way, how many character arcs get warped into incoherence, grim futility, or total fucking nihilism by the gravitational pull of these endings. Like. Wow, I retroactively dislike other movies because this is apparently where you were going that whole time! AWESOME. THANKS I HATE IT.



https://dsudis.tumblr.com/post/184459811109/endgame-thoughts-i-guess-spoilers-under-the-cut




#2

Another Endgame thought, this one about Steve and his storyline. Which I am not squeeing about in this post.

Okay, so, everyone always sees a different version of the same movie, right, we all know that.

But it is fucking SURREAL to see a character’s ending and go “wow that was an only barely metaphorical suicide concluding his six-movie arc of depression and alienation, I need to go huddle with The Magicians fans now” and then have people cheering about what a beautiful and romantic and life-affirming happy ending it was.

https://dsudis.tumblr.com/post/184465063904/another-endgame-thought-this-one-about-steve-and




#3

Third and perhaps most inevitable Endgame Thought

…oh no I just spent an hour plotting out the fic I want to write to fix EVERYTHING.

https://dsudis.tumblr.com/post/184467130094/third-and-perhaps-most-inevitable-endgame-thought
mecurtin: fandom compass: porn/wank/spoilers/meta and so around (fandom compass)

[personal profile] mecurtin 2019-04-27 04:50 am (UTC)(link)
Whut.

OK, I'm not going to use up valuable brain cycles thinking about this, I will continue in my conviction that not seeing this in a theater (or any place where I can't pause or fast-forward) is a good life choice.
calime: Windows system message box with heading"Canon error" under that Apply fanfic? and under that button OK (canon error fix)

[personal profile] calime 2019-04-27 12:42 pm (UTC)(link)
I made the same choice, and I am feeling really really good about this.
mollyamory: Coffee (Default)

[personal profile] mollyamory 2019-04-27 12:46 pm (UTC)(link)
You are not wrong about any of that. And I'll add that in the course of the movie he exchanged not a single word with Tony, so that kind of sucked for me pairing-wise.

But the good part, for me anyway, is that because he spent the entire movie in the uncanny valley of not!Bruce and not!Hulk, it was almost like he wasn't even there. Every time he was on screen he basically negated the movie for me as something to take seriously - it was like he was a cartoon character in a live-action movie. Makes it a lot easier for me to emotionally exclude it all from canon as needed!
kore: (Default)

[personal profile] kore 2019-05-04 08:32 am (UTC)(link)
That was weird about some big parts of the movie -- the screenwriters said, what do you do if they lose, and it was like, Steve leads a support group, Nat becomes a "shut-in" (no really they said "shut-in"), Clint goes on a rampage and Bruce becomes a superhero and Tony retires. So in a weird way Bruce and Tony get their happy endings first, and both happen offscreen -- clearly Tony and Pepper came to an understanding and got married and had a kid (and fairly soon after the Snap, apparently), and Bruce integrates his two personas after they were so completely split in Ragnarok and IW. And in the heroic ending, Tony is dead (I wasn't thrilled that apparently the solution to PTSD is to....die killing what traumatized you) and Bruce is terribly injured, and he doesn't sit out the final fight but he's not part of the three-on-one Heroic Trio taking down Thanos. And his snap, which actually brings everyone back, is much more subdued (and instantly overshadowed) and IIRC takes longer than the results of Tony's snap.